Live Chat 6 PM to 9 PM EST
ONE VOICE Chat Community
Stories Of Human Torture By the VA Process
The Incapacity Doctrine|
Go
![]() |
New
![]() |
Find
![]() |
Notify
![]() |
Tools
![]() |
Reply
![]() |
|
|
Member |
This Blog is not written by an
attorney, as any licensed lawyer would not have the military balls to say what I'm about to say. ___________________________________ For those of you Parrot-Heads who delusionally insist on the unfounded idea that VSO's actually know what they are doing in the big confounded arena of VA disability claims, hold onto your canteens because I'm about to walk you down the road of the clueless and prove to you one of the million reasons why pro bono licensed lawyers ought to be brought into our SCC claims system pronto, regardless of all the whining and footstomping that is done by the unqualified and incompetent VSO's. There is, in law, a little known principle called Incapacity or Want Of Capacity. It's usually found in the indexes of state law books. Here in New York it is included in the New York Jurisprudence set, and at the federal level, you may also find a few limited entries under American Jurisprudence. If you go out to Google.com and do a double search as follows, then you can pull out several Hits at a time on the subject: "incapacitated person" AND law More than likely you have never heard of it in the Veterans arena, and this is because the VA violates it almost every time a new disability VA Form 21-526 is processed by them, and because the VSO Representatives are too unqualified, untrained, and malpracticed to enforce it, plead it, use it for the Defense of sick Veterans, apply it, invoke it, organize a protest on it, insist on it's recognition, or even to speak on it or track it within this corrupt, cruel, and serial-killer like VA disability system. The Incapacity doctrine has been out there all this time just waiting for somebody with a brain to use it in the Defense of sick Veterans. But when you have an entire VSO army of Tweedle Dees, know-nothings, patriot Parrot-Heads who question nothing, self-absorbed title chasers, bored low I.Q.'s who don't know enough to go home and have a good life, and other disabled types who are often even more disabled than YOU are, then it stands to reason that this list of misfits who need to find something else to do, would easily slip on by the more finer details and minutia of such important Vet Defenses as the Incapacity doctrine. Yes it's the stupid leading the sick, and it's hard to believe that some of us are actually suckered into supporting such malpracticed nonsense. Legal Incapacity, or a person who is Incapacitated, is when that person is no longer able to either handle their own affairs and personal matters, OR protect themselves from harm. The test for this varies across the states. In New York, for instance, the test is expanded to also say that persons who are unable to defend or prosecute their rights are also valid and included definitions of Incapacity. One of the big reasons why Incapacity is a legal blur on the books, sometimes even to the licensed lawyers themselves, is that Incapacity is very often folded into the very same statute which also protects Incompetent persons. So Incapacity and Incompetency are often dealt with in the same body of law, and it requires focused reading and the sorting out of case citation histories to figure out where one ends and the other begins. An Incompetent person is not necessarily the same as an Incapacitated person, although in some cases, one person can be both. Usually a person is either Incapacitated OR Incompetent. A coma patient is Incapacitated, a developmentally retarded person is Incompetent, to give examples of extremes. Some misguided lawyers in their rush on readings, are making the mistake of referring to Incapacitated persons when they really mean to make the important distinction of Incompetent persons. Unfortunately in our Vets arena, we don't have to worry about any of it because the VSO's have been asleep at the wheel all this time and I was hard pressed to find a single VA case citation where Incapacity was ever pleaded by any VSO. Incapacity is often founded on the realistic idea that a person must be, and is required to be, in a full physical and mental state to absorb, comprehend, process, and appropriately respond to a legal proceeding, otherwise that legal proceeding is viewed by the courts as invalid. In short, if you are too sick to know what is going on in a legal proceeding, too under the influence of treatment or medicine, then that legal proceeding is as good as gone. In criminal law, you will sometimes hear in high profile cases on TV, that a suspect must undergo a competency hearing prior to a bail hearing. This is to sort out the rights of the Defendant and make sure that he or she can absorb and comprehend the legal proceedings which they are about to undergo. The same is true in civil law, but only if you invoke it and plead it. If it is never pleaded or invoked, then the Court is clueless about whether or not Incapacity is an appropriate application to the case. Here lies the doom of silence, bungling, and incompetence that the VSO's have been cranking out for entire decades in Veterans disability cases. The Incapacity doctrine, you see, extends out to hospital and medical patients. It's an immunity pleading against the VA which has never been used. If you are in the hospital, or at home with a major illness such as cancer, diabetes, multiple sclerosis, etc. - and especially if you are under the care of a Home Health Aide and so on, then an Incapacity pleading is waiting to be plucked from the books and entered into a VA law proceeding in YOUR name. The problem here, (as you are starting to guess me out,) is that the VA has been conducting a full, adversarial, court of law proceeding against hospitalized and medical patients who ARE wholly Incapacited, but not necessary Incompetent. None of these medical patients have had access to a pro bono licensed lawyer because of the bungling "volunteer" system that is run by the VSO's. DAV etc. has subverted and sabotaged all third-party representation to the Veterans disability claims arena, and now there are no licensed lawyers taking Vet disability cases. Some of us are now uniting to bring a quick and decisive END to this outragous and cruel legal malpractice. In their relentless stupidty, VSO's have done even more harm to the Incapacity immunity Defense by posting themselves INSIDE the VA Hospital system, and walking up and down the halls, in and out of patient rooms, getting the Veterans to SIGN VA DISABILITY LEGAL PAPERS WHILE THEY ARE IMMUNIFIED BY THE INCAPACITY DEFENSE If THAT doesn't blow your socks off with shock and awe then I don't know what will !! Any Human Rights lawyer who knows a little something about medical patient rights would be stunned at this practice by the unsupervised sanctioning of VSO's doing this to Vet patients at the VA Hospitals. So on the one hand, the statutes are set up to protect hospital and medical Veterans from being forced and coerced into a full blown disability litigation proceeding against well-funded, high-paid, licensed and career-experienced attorneys who are representing the VA agency like prosecutors on the prowl; and on the other hand, dysfunctional and unqualified misfits running around on behalf of the DAV, VFW, etc. are shoving VA legal papers into the faces of bedridden medical patients for a quick signature, with the patients not even with enough bearings to know what it is that they are putting a signature to. If that doesn't stop you cold under the .....cruel and unusual... category then there is something wrong with YOU !! Make no mistake that the VA fully comprehends the joke behind all of this. They are conducting full adversarial court and legal LITIGATION upon lawfully shielded hospital and medical patients who are Incapacited and are without any access whatsoever to licensed, pro bono lawyers. And the VSO Reps from StupidVille are running around trashing the immunity protections of the patients without ever pleading Incapacity on the patients behalf in front of the VA litigation system. The VA's claim forms in general, as well as the policy itself of conducting full adversarial legal proceedings on Incapacitated medical patients are all illegal if not unconstitutional and is fully overturnable if the right law firm came along and chose to take that on. In short, the whole system is overturnable if only we could find the right law firm to represent the Veterans of America as a general class, instead of us as a "club membership" such as with American Legion. If anything, this Blog will be an instant revelation to many of you as to just how far off the mark the VSO's have been in processing Veterans claims, and it will also be your wakeup call as to just how close we are to making HUGE national change in this cruel and corrupt VA system. Yes it's just around the corner if only we would organize and pursue a major class action law firm. Veterans who felt pressured to sign VA claims papers while in the VAMC Hospital, can reopen their cases and claim the Incapacity Defense stating they were without the required intellectual bearings to know or understand the true scope of the VA legal proceeding that was previously signed for. The federal VA statutes to invoke and plead are 38 CFR 20.301 and 38 CFR 17.33(a)(4). If you want to go further and plead that the VA proceedings are completely illegal or unconstitutional on the grounds that all persons claiming VA disability are already designated Incapacitated persons, then knock yourself out in pursuing that Defense too. This doesn't mean you will win your case since the VA routinely falsifies the dockets on the VA computers. All of law enforcement is completely suspended inside the VA. This has been verified time and time again by many Veterans. What it will do, however, is set you on the trail of reopening your cases, new appeals, perhaps even qualifying for a licensed pro bono lawyer at the Veterans Pro Bono Consortium after you have left the BVA. Because the VSO's have been dropping the ball at every turn on the Incapacity Defense, (probably to make themselves look more important in the Veterans arena than they really are), there are little or no case citations in the statutory stream for Incapacity pleadings at the VA. (Thanks for nothing you VSO morons!!) But starting a new chain of citations on the Incapacity doctrine is open to us to pursue, with or without a lawyer, so this might be a new strategy where we can all help each other. Start supporting some of the Vet advocacy efforts in our arena to force the VA to provide pro bono licensed lawyers to all medical patients, OR otherwise completely abandon their Guantanamo-like pursuits of conducting adversarial legal proceedings on verified medical patients altogether. And always but always, begin advocating that the VSO's completely get out of the illegal business of running law franchises for Veterans claims without ever providing a single licensed attorney to any Veteran. Tweedle Dee representation is no representation at all. Sue Frasier, VEV 1970 Army Signal Corps national activist/protester staff Blogger, VFJ |
||
|
|
Member |
Sue you have hit many points on the mark.
Incompetence and Incapacitation are definately two distinctly different conditions and there are laws set in place for civilians to address that. Veterans however are forced to submit to a "system" that is breaking all the laws. It's crazy that there are two different standards, and worlds, one for civilians and one for veterans/prior & present military. How can a government that insists its citizens obey the laws not follow suit within their own dealings and get away with it? Our government needs to be held accountable to the double standards and yes we need more attorneys who are not afraid to speak out. With regards to the VRO's they are not trained in legal procedings. Any knowledge they have gleaned about the law, has been on their own time, of this I am almost certain. Maybe YOU Sue should pursue law, you certainly have the mind for it. Incapacitated people who are not incompetent can be dangerous people, because while their individual body parts may not still work, there is one body part that still does, it is the mind. The mind & the right voice, two awesome combinations. In my search today I ran across invitation to attorneys to work pro bono for veterans. To the attorneys: We really would like your help!! We need it! Please don't let it be a family member of yours that falls in the same trap we are in to make you want to assist. |
|||
|
|
Member |
Sue Frasier, VEV 1970 Army Signal Corps national activist/protester staff Blogger, VFJ |
|||
|
| Powered by Eve Community |
| Please Wait. Your request is being processed... |
|

